Rate the performance of Scottish referee Hollie Davidson in the Bok win against Italy on Saturday
Referee Review: Hollie Davidson Holds Her Own in Bok Victory Over Italy
In a landmark moment for international rugby, Scottish referee Hollie Davidson took charge of the Springboks’ season-opening clash against Italy in Pretoria on Saturday. As the second woman ever to officiate a Test involving the Springboks, all eyes were on Davidson—and she delivered a performance marked by calm authority and clear communication.
From the first whistle, Davidson demonstrated control and composure. Known for her confident style, she allowed the match to flow without unnecessary interference, a quality often praised by both players and coaches in her previous international and United Rugby Championship appointments. Despite the intensity of the match, particularly at the breakdowns and scrum engagements, Davidson managed the pace of the game expertly.
Her communication with the players was a standout feature. She remained firm in her instructions while maintaining respect on both sides. The players responded well to her presence, which speaks volumes about the mutual trust she builds on the field. Even in moments of potential confrontation, such as high tackles or slowing of the ball at the ruck, Davidson kept control without needing to resort to excessive penalties or cards.
What further impressed observers was her use of the TMO. Rather than over-relying on video referrals, she used the technology judiciously, trusting her own instincts and positioning. This contributed to a smoother viewing experience and helped maintain the game’s momentum.
While some may argue that a few scrum resets could have been managed more proactively, it was clear that her primary focus was on fairness and clarity. Her overall consistency throughout the match ensured that neither side felt aggrieved by the officiating.
Hollie Davidson’s performance was a testament to her growing stature in world rugby. She handled the Springboks-Italy encounter with a level of professionalism and authority befitting the occasion. With performances like this, there’s little doubt she’ll continue to receive more high-profile Test appointments. Her rating? A confident and well-earned 8.5 out of 10.
